Ancient Hedgerow destroyed at one of Britain's last city farms
- 6 months ago
One of Britain’s last city farmers is devastated after workers tore up a section of an ancient hedgerow.
Catherine Withers, 53, and her supporters were in tears as developers removed the 200-year-old hedge with chainsaws.
Catherine's family has worked Yew Tree Farm in Chew Magna, just south of Bristol, for almost 60 years.
But now contractors who have plans to build a new housing development have removed a section of an ancient hedgerow.
The hedge is a Site of Nature Conservation Interest (SNCI) because it is home to a wide variety of birds, butterflies, and insects.
Catherine used to graze her cattle in the field before the landowners terminated the agreement.
Earlier this year apparent ''errors' made by Bristol City Council saw the landowner given permission to build a 12-foot gate.
The local authority has since admitted that it made a mistake but due to the time that has passed it cannot go back on the decision.
The gate has been installed to give new access to fields that developers hope to build houses on.
But Catherine says this could lead to the farm becoming financially unviable for her family.
Tenant farmer Catherine, who was left in tears at the incident, said: “It makes me weep that it’s such an important site but it can’t be protected.
"Now we've got an industrial gateway across a green space that is teeming with life - including a new species known to science.
"I’m completely broken - the little guy always loses.
“The people that want to destroy anything green and natural are winning and people that want to protect the natural world are losing.
“I’m absolutely gobsmacked that’s where we are with Bristol City Council’s planning department.
'“It’s not just about the gap in the bush, because I suppose a hedgerow could survive a four-meter gap.
“This hedgerow is ancient and protected because it has so much biodiversity.
“There are hundreds of butterflies as well as birds nesting and bats, all known to use the hedgerow.”
John Tarlton, of Bristol Tree Forum, said: ''Nature is going to be destroyed and that is exactly what we don't want.''
The area was designated a Site of Nature Conservation Interest (SNCI) - following the discovery of an insect currently unknown to science there.
In a letter seen by Bristol24/7 earlier this year a city council planning enforcement team member admitted that errors had been made by the council during the application process.
It said “it transpires that we did not properly realise what the application was and treated it like a request for info on proposed works to trees”.
The email said: “This is the first application of this type for many years, and we accept that our Administration and Business Support Team made a mistake – we have put in place a process to ensure that such an error is not repeated.”
A spokesperson for Bristol City Council said: “Officers are investigating whether works undertaken by the landowner are in accordance with the planning permission in place and conform to the ecological method statement agreed with the consultant ecologists.
“No evidence has been submitted at present to suggest any breach of planning permission.
"Officers will continue to monitor the works to ensure they remain in line with the agreed plans in place.”
The privately owned land in Bedminster Down has been the site of a long-running battle between the landowner and Catherine.
Attempts to build 200 new homes on the space have been thwarted so far with the council’s latest Local Plan, its 15-year housing blueprint, protecting it from future development.
Landowners Longmoor Land Limited (LLL) LLL said they had acted "in exact accordance" with planning permission.
A spokesperson said they had "created a new 12ft access in the hedgerow from the lane to their own land solely for agricultural purposes".
They told the BBC: "The previous access to the field had been via land owned by Mrs Withers of Yew Tree Farm (who had grazed the Longmoor Land fields under a grazing licence).
"However, since that grazing licence was terminated last year, a new access is now required, and this has been put in place today.
"Longmoor Land is at the same time planting 250ft of new hedgerow in the same field, replacing the amount of hedgerow removed around 20 times over.''
Catherine Withers, 53, and her supporters were in tears as developers removed the 200-year-old hedge with chainsaws.
Catherine's family has worked Yew Tree Farm in Chew Magna, just south of Bristol, for almost 60 years.
But now contractors who have plans to build a new housing development have removed a section of an ancient hedgerow.
The hedge is a Site of Nature Conservation Interest (SNCI) because it is home to a wide variety of birds, butterflies, and insects.
Catherine used to graze her cattle in the field before the landowners terminated the agreement.
Earlier this year apparent ''errors' made by Bristol City Council saw the landowner given permission to build a 12-foot gate.
The local authority has since admitted that it made a mistake but due to the time that has passed it cannot go back on the decision.
The gate has been installed to give new access to fields that developers hope to build houses on.
But Catherine says this could lead to the farm becoming financially unviable for her family.
Tenant farmer Catherine, who was left in tears at the incident, said: “It makes me weep that it’s such an important site but it can’t be protected.
"Now we've got an industrial gateway across a green space that is teeming with life - including a new species known to science.
"I’m completely broken - the little guy always loses.
“The people that want to destroy anything green and natural are winning and people that want to protect the natural world are losing.
“I’m absolutely gobsmacked that’s where we are with Bristol City Council’s planning department.
'“It’s not just about the gap in the bush, because I suppose a hedgerow could survive a four-meter gap.
“This hedgerow is ancient and protected because it has so much biodiversity.
“There are hundreds of butterflies as well as birds nesting and bats, all known to use the hedgerow.”
John Tarlton, of Bristol Tree Forum, said: ''Nature is going to be destroyed and that is exactly what we don't want.''
The area was designated a Site of Nature Conservation Interest (SNCI) - following the discovery of an insect currently unknown to science there.
In a letter seen by Bristol24/7 earlier this year a city council planning enforcement team member admitted that errors had been made by the council during the application process.
It said “it transpires that we did not properly realise what the application was and treated it like a request for info on proposed works to trees”.
The email said: “This is the first application of this type for many years, and we accept that our Administration and Business Support Team made a mistake – we have put in place a process to ensure that such an error is not repeated.”
A spokesperson for Bristol City Council said: “Officers are investigating whether works undertaken by the landowner are in accordance with the planning permission in place and conform to the ecological method statement agreed with the consultant ecologists.
“No evidence has been submitted at present to suggest any breach of planning permission.
"Officers will continue to monitor the works to ensure they remain in line with the agreed plans in place.”
The privately owned land in Bedminster Down has been the site of a long-running battle between the landowner and Catherine.
Attempts to build 200 new homes on the space have been thwarted so far with the council’s latest Local Plan, its 15-year housing blueprint, protecting it from future development.
Landowners Longmoor Land Limited (LLL) LLL said they had acted "in exact accordance" with planning permission.
A spokesperson said they had "created a new 12ft access in the hedgerow from the lane to their own land solely for agricultural purposes".
They told the BBC: "The previous access to the field had been via land owned by Mrs Withers of Yew Tree Farm (who had grazed the Longmoor Land fields under a grazing licence).
"However, since that grazing licence was terminated last year, a new access is now required, and this has been put in place today.
"Longmoor Land is at the same time planting 250ft of new hedgerow in the same field, replacing the amount of hedgerow removed around 20 times over.''