'Lockdown & Hardship Faced by Poor Raise Constitutional Concerns But Don't Look to SC for Answers'
- 3 years ago
The 3 week old national lockdown has raised atleast two key constitutional concerns and the govt’s attempt to mitigate its adverse impact on the poor and vulnerable has raised a third says the legal scholar Gautam Bhatia. However the Supreme Court’s response is disappointing.
In a 30 minute Skype interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire from Oxford, Gautam Bhatia said that a national lockdown which disproportionately affects the poor and vulnerable compared to the rich and comfortable, breaches the equality clauses of the Indian constitution (Article 14) as well the right to life guaranteed by Article 21. Elaborating on the second point, Mr Bhatia said the Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that the right to life is more than “bare animal existence.” However, tens if not hundreds of millions of daily wage workers have been reduced to a bare animal existence. Clearly, therefore, their right to life has been affected.
However, Mr Bhatia told The Wire the govt can legitimately argue that a lockdown is necessary for the greater good and this is a policy matter and not one for the courts to entertain. He does not believe the courts will entertain these concerns. But the adequacy of the govt’s mitigation efforts to alleviate the suffering of the poor and vulnerable is another matter altogether.
Mr Bhatia told The Wire that because the constitutional rights of the poor and vulnerable have been affected (Articles 14 and 21) the govt has a constitutional duty and not just a social or moral responsibility to adequately mitigate the plight of the poor and vulnerable. He said the govt cannot escape this or dilute its response on the grounds it cannot afford adequate mitigation. There is a minimum core that the govt has to provide which, Mr Bhatia said, is the level of living daily wage workers had before the lockdown. The govt has to find the money to fulfil this constitutional duty.
Mr Bhatia said as things stand daily wage workers have fallen below the minimum core and this is an issue that can and has been raised in the courts. However Mr Bhatia is disappointed by the response form the courts and was critical of a comment attributed to Chief Justice Bobde who reportedly said if wage workers are getting food why do they need money.
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: https://thewire.in/support
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: http://thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: http://thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: https://marathi.thewire.in
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry – anything that’s straight out of your imagination – to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. https://livewire.thewire.in/
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/TheWire/
https://www.facebook.com/TheWireHindi/
https://www.facebook.com/TheWireUrdu/
https://www.facebook.com/TheWireMarathi/
Twitter
https://twitter.com/thewire_in
https://twitter.com/thewirehindi
https://twitter.com/TheWireUrdu
https://twitter.com/TheWireMarathi
https://twitter.com/livewire
Instagram
https://www.instagram.com/thewirein/
https://www.instagram.com/livewirein/
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!
In a 30 minute Skype interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire from Oxford, Gautam Bhatia said that a national lockdown which disproportionately affects the poor and vulnerable compared to the rich and comfortable, breaches the equality clauses of the Indian constitution (Article 14) as well the right to life guaranteed by Article 21. Elaborating on the second point, Mr Bhatia said the Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that the right to life is more than “bare animal existence.” However, tens if not hundreds of millions of daily wage workers have been reduced to a bare animal existence. Clearly, therefore, their right to life has been affected.
However, Mr Bhatia told The Wire the govt can legitimately argue that a lockdown is necessary for the greater good and this is a policy matter and not one for the courts to entertain. He does not believe the courts will entertain these concerns. But the adequacy of the govt’s mitigation efforts to alleviate the suffering of the poor and vulnerable is another matter altogether.
Mr Bhatia told The Wire that because the constitutional rights of the poor and vulnerable have been affected (Articles 14 and 21) the govt has a constitutional duty and not just a social or moral responsibility to adequately mitigate the plight of the poor and vulnerable. He said the govt cannot escape this or dilute its response on the grounds it cannot afford adequate mitigation. There is a minimum core that the govt has to provide which, Mr Bhatia said, is the level of living daily wage workers had before the lockdown. The govt has to find the money to fulfil this constitutional duty.
Mr Bhatia said as things stand daily wage workers have fallen below the minimum core and this is an issue that can and has been raised in the courts. However Mr Bhatia is disappointed by the response form the courts and was critical of a comment attributed to Chief Justice Bobde who reportedly said if wage workers are getting food why do they need money.
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: https://thewire.in/support
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: http://thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: http://thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: https://marathi.thewire.in
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry – anything that’s straight out of your imagination – to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. https://livewire.thewire.in/
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
https://www.facebook.com/TheWire/
https://www.facebook.com/TheWireHindi/
https://www.facebook.com/TheWireUrdu/
https://www.facebook.com/TheWireMarathi/
https://twitter.com/thewire_in
https://twitter.com/thewirehindi
https://twitter.com/TheWireUrdu
https://twitter.com/TheWireMarathi
https://twitter.com/livewire
https://www.instagram.com/thewirein/
https://www.instagram.com/livewirein/
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!