According to Business Insider, fans of "Bachelor in Paradise" were surprised to see a picture contestant Jared Haibon posted on his Instagram of him, his fiance Ashley Iaconetti, Ashton Kutcher, and MIla Kunis. Apparently, fans have been conspiring about how Haibon and Kunis look so much like each other. In the picture, both men had fun and admitted the fan theories were right. Haibon wrote in the caption, "In 2015, Ashton Kutcher tweeted a side by side photo of our faces.